72 Hempstead Street, Sag Harbor, NY 11963

The Hempstead House

Not every home has a name. This one earned it. Meticulously renovated within Sag Harbor Village, 72 Hempstead is a masterclass in sophisticated design, where every detail was considered and nothing overlooked. Four bedrooms and four full baths span 1,838 square feet on 0.14 acres, complemented by a heated gunite pool and landscaping shaped by years of care. The open-concept living and dining room commands attention with its vaulted ceiling and wood-burning fireplace, opening onto an outdoor dining terrace made for gathering, whether hosting a full table or an intimate dinner. The kitchen rewards cooks and non-cooks alike with a marble-topped center island, farmhouse sink, handcrafted glazed tile backsplash, and top-of-the-line appliances. Each bedroom tells its own story: a first-floor junior suite opens to secluded gardens and an outdoor shower, a second guest suite is just moments from the pool and backyard, and the lower level offers a bright, private retreat with an en-suite bath. The primary suite claims its own corner of the upper level, with views over the landscaped grounds and a spa bath featuring a soaking tub, steam shower, and radiant-heated floors. Private, lush, and just as considered as the interior, the exterior is a true extension of the home. With a competitive rental history, 72 Hempstead presents a rare, truly turnkey opportunity in Sag Harbor Village.